Shh... A Message from The Librarians They Could Not Silence
Arkansas's librarians are speaking up. It's time to listen.
Maybe it’s common knowledge, but we have an overwhelming suspicion that the vast majority of Arkansans know very little about the inner workings of government culture, both locally and at the state level. We can all be naive, assuming anything associated with the government is straightforward and law-abiding. A person runs for office, signs the necessary paperwork, campaigns, shakes hands, kisses babies, wins the election, takes an oath, and goes to work “serving the people.”
But regular citizens are mostly left out of the culture that develops around power and influence in government-affiliated work, and the expectation that sometimes accompanies it: allegiance.
The weight is heavy. Follow directions, toe the line, and keep your mouth shut.
Things many of us take for granted every day are the ability to speak up, share our opinions, post ideas, or even have basic interactions on social media. Those freedoms disappear when you work in certain government capacities, especially education or public service.
Why share this now? Where is this coming from?
We’re tired.
Librarians know what happens inside the building because they are the ones who have to make it work. They are the people behind the scenes. Often faceless. Often nameless. Often invisible.
When political battles come, librarians often become stepping stones.
One can only deprive oneself of sharing the stories, experiences, and truths that have shaped them for so long before the silence becomes its own burden. This isn’t limited to protecting our patrons and the people we serve; it is also about protecting ourselves. We’ve reached the chapter in the story where we’re being instructed to remove ourselves from meetings, made to step outside of rooms we’ve always been in and left out of conversations that involve the future of our field. One occurrence is a mistake; repeated behavior is a pattern. This isn’t an accident. It’s intentional, and it’s methodical.
Arkansas law provides a specific statutory framework for public libraries, including the Arkansas State Library, county libraries, joint city-county libraries, and regional library systems, each with its own specifications and infrastructures. Arkansas law doesn’t treat every public library as though it were simply another department within county government. In fact, the framework empowers library boards with defined responsibilities and authority over the operation, finances, facilities, and personnel. For example, library boards have authority over library funds and, depending on the type of library, the appointment and supervision of library leadership. That distinction matters.
Somewhere along the way, politics leaked into one of the last nonpartisan and objective institutions left in our communities. A library falls between a small civic ecosystem and a third space, encouraging people to learn, belong, and come together to access information. None of which require any political affiliation. In fact, many of us working in Arkansas Library Land consider election season a success if our patrons actually remember to vote, regardless of who they support. Yet increasingly, libraries have become talking points themselves, particularly during campaign seasons.
Many public libraries are funded, at least in part, through a local millage, and county librarians (sometimes called directors or branch managers) are responsible for the day-to-day operation of their libraries, including buildings, payroll, budgets, collections, programs, and staff. Yet those same librarians can find themselves discredited or disparaged by colleagues, not within the library profession, but throughout the broader government structure. Librarians are treated as though they are “less valuable,” their expertise is dismissed, and their authority is questioned.
We have firsthand accounts of county officials questioning the credibility of librarians, challenging their authority, limiting their ability to process board-approved purchases, and even questioning the salaries of county librarians when those decisions were made through the library’s own governing structure. Sadly, this is not an isolated interaction. We have witnessed, time and again, situations in which librarians are treated as though they are somehow less valuable, less knowledgeable, or less entitled to protection and respect than other public servants.
Not only is that disrespectful, but it also reflects a basic misunderstanding of the professional structure of public libraries. A librarian is not simply another county employee whose authority exists at the discretion of whichever county official happens to question it. Public libraries operate within their own legal and governing frameworks, and the people responsible for those libraries deserve to have that authority recognized and respected.
This isn’t a question of who is right or who is wrong. It is a matter of respect, professional boundaries, and allegiance to the status quo. County clerks, sheriffs, assessors, judges, and other county officials have established professional associations that provide training, continuing education, resources, and opportunities to work with others serving in the same role. The Arkansas Association of Counties, for example, represents, trains, and hosts continuing education events for county elected governments, but librarians obviously occupy a different space.
Our profession has its own professional network, and Arkansas law places public libraries within a framework administered and supported through the Arkansas State Library and the Arkansas State Library Board. One would think that, when county officials have questions about the structure, authority, or responsibilities of public libraries, there would be an obvious avenue for education and clarification.
One would think.
And yet, here we are.
Library boards and libraries themselves have become battlegrounds for issues that extend well beyond the operation of a library. People with limited understanding of the profession are attempting to redefine it. At the same time, librarians are increasingly asked to defend and implement outside decisions that the law actually places within the authority of their governing boards. Professional expertise is too often dismissed when it becomes inconvenient, and those who are closest to the work are increasingly expected to justify costly decisions they’ve had no say in making. Recently, library staff members were asked to leave an open public meeting held by a county library board, while an existing member of our state legislature was permitted to stay. Routinely, we see conversations happening involving the future of our profession, without the people who actually do the work being allowed to remain in the room.
When a seat on a library board is less about serving the library and its community and more about advancing an agenda, the integrity of the institution begins to suffer. The problem is not necessarily that boards are corrupt. The problem is what happens when a position intended to serve a public institution becomes a vehicle for political influence or political gain.
More alarmingly, we’ve witnessed a statewide legal and political attack involving public libraries, consistently framed as “protecting children.” Meanwhile, libraries have consistently asked for practical partnerships, preventative training, and hands-on resources to address safety concerns. If a proposed solution doesn’t align with a particular political agenda, it is not considered a viable option.
For us, protecting children is not a political slogan. It’s part of our job. We want safe libraries. We want safe communities. We want children to be safe. We want our staff to be safe. For all of this, we need practical solutions that address these goals. When solutions are overlooked or ignored, it’s reasonable to ask why. And that’s one of the pieces missing from the story.
The people doing the actual work are often not necessarily the people standing with the microphone. They are not the names in the headlines. They are not the people appearing in campaign advertisements. However, they are the ones answering questions at a circulation desk, reading a book during storytime, sitting through a meeting that could’ve been an email, and trying their best to understand another new mandate, with little to no instructions provided from the county’s legal counsel.
We have spent years being the good guys. We have the success stories, the photographs, the children who learned to read, the families who found resources they could not find anywhere else, and the patrons who needed a place and found one. We will always have those stories to cling to, and we will always be proud of them.
But always being the good guy doesn’t mean we’re endlessly compliant. It doesn’t mean we’re incapable of recognizing what is happening around us. And it does not mean we’ll quietly accept being pushed out of the room.
A person can only be excluded from so many meetings. A person can only be told to be quiet for so long. A person can only watch decisions being made about their profession without their voice for so long before they finally decide that their voice matters, too.
And maybe that’s the irony of all of this.
A librarian: the person assumed to be meek, quiet, and perhaps even a little boring. While there may be some truth to that stereotype for some of us, there are other facets to librarianship that people rarely see.
We are advocates. We are researchers. We are defenders of information. We are community builders. We are stubborn. And we have voices, too.
It's time we use them. Not because we want a fight, but because sometimes protecting the people we serve requires us to stand up when we would much rather be reading a book.
So, shhhh...
Maybe we were quiet for a while. Maybe we followed the rules. Maybe we stayed in our lanes. Maybe we trusted that if we did our jobs well enough, served our communities faithfully enough, and kept our heads down long enough, someone would eventually recognize that we were worth listening to.
But the librarians are talking now, and we won’t be silent.